A federal district court in Massachusetts blocked a finalized Department of Homeland Security rule that would have ended the open-ended “duration of status” system for F-1 student visas, J-1 exchange visitor visas, and I media visas. Under the current system, these visa holders can remain in the United States for as long as they maintain their program or status, with no fixed end date. The rule would have replaced that with set time limits: a maximum of four years for F-1 and J-1 visas, and 240 days for I visas. 

The lawsuit, Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration v. United States Department of Homeland Security, was brought by a coalition of left-wing organizations that includes the Presidents’ Alliance, NAFSA (the Association of International Educators), the American Federation of Teachers, and the Graduate Labor Organization. The plaintiffs argued that the rule was arbitrary and capricious, and the judge ruled in their favor. 

While the Left achieved a temporary victory, DHS is expected to appeal to the First Circuit Court of Appeals.

Under the current Duration of Status system, foreign students on F-1 visas can stay in the United States for as long as they are enrolled in school, with no set end date. Once they finish their degree, the same open-ended status continues into another degree program or Optional Practical Training (OPT), which lets them work in the U.S. for up to one year, or three years in STEM fields. Because they never have to leave the country, many then move straight into H-1B visas and other long-term work permits. This creates a direct pipeline from foreign student to U.S. worker, taking jobs from American graduates at a time when many American STEM graduates can’t find a job in their field. 

The new DHS rule would have interrupted this pipeline, and returned student visas to their original intended purpose: education.

Texans for Strong Borders believes the federal government should end the H-1B visa program and reform the other facets of legal immigration that disproportionately displace highly-skilled American workers.